Green claims you can prove.

Analysis

Comparing products on the environment: the three legal frames a comparison can fall into, and what each one requires

“30% less plastic than our previous bottle”, “a lower footprint than brand X”, a ranking of products by carbon footprint: three comparisons, three frames. What the definition of an environmental claim, the comparative advertising rules and the new Article 7(7) require, and what the recitals expect of any comparison.

Jeremy Fain · Published on 2 November 2026 · Updated on 13 November 2026 · 4 min read

The question this article answers
Can a brand say its product has “30% less impact” than a competitor’s?

In 40 words: Only on equivalent terms. The comparison must not mislead, must concern products meeting the same needs and must compare material, relevant, verifiable and representative features; recital 6 of Directive 2024/825 adds the same function, a common method and common assumptions.

Your own pages: the free scan reads up to five of your addresses and links the claims it finds to the rules that concern them, with their source.

Run a free scan

Every comparison is an environmental claim

The definition names comparisons explicitly. Under Article 2(o) of Directive 2005/29/EC, an environmental claim includes any message stating or implying that a product, brand or trader “is less damaging to the environment than other products, product categories, brands or traders, or has improved its impact over time”. Articles 6 and 7 on misleading actions and omissions apply to it.

A comparison with the past is a comparison too. “30% less plastic” compares the product with an earlier version of itself. The reference version or year, what was measured and on which part of the product are what make that figure checkable.

When a competitor can be identified

Comparative advertising has its own conditions. Directive 2006/114/EC defines it as advertising that explicitly or by implication identifies a competitor or a competitor’s goods. Article 4 permits it only if it is not misleading, compares goods meeting the same needs or intended for the same purpose, and objectively compares one or more material, relevant, verifiable and representative features; it may not denigrate a competitor or create confusion.

France and Germany carry the same conditions. Articles L. 122-1 and L. 122-2 of the French Consumer Code set them for advertising that identifies a competitor; section 6 of the German UWG treats as unfair a comparison that does not relate objectively to essential, relevant, verifiable and typical features.

When the trader runs the comparison

Article 7(7) adds a duty for comparison services. Since 27 September 2026, where a trader provides a service that compares products and informs consumers on environmental or social characteristics or circularity aspects, such as durability, reparability or recyclability, the method of comparison, the products compared, their suppliers and the measures to keep the information up to date are material information.

Rankings and filters can be such a service. A retailer that sorts its range by footprint, or a site that scores products by recyclability, compares products; leaving out the method or the date of the data then risks a misleading omission.

National texts follow. Germany has the rule in section 5b(3a) UWG. France had not transposed it on 1 November 2026; bill No 2518 would add it to Article L. 121-3 of the Consumer Code.

What any comparison should respect

Recital 6 sets the standard of objectivity. Comparisons should be objective, “in particular, comparing products which serve the same function, using a common method and common assumptions, and comparing material and verifiable features of the products being compared”.

The Green Claims proposal would have gone further. Its Article 4 would require equivalent information and data for the products compared, produced or sourced in an equivalent manner; the proposal, which the Commission has proposed to withdraw since 4 November 2026, was never adopted.

Questions we hear

Is a comparison with an industry average comparative advertising? Not if no competitor can be identified. It remains an environmental claim under Article 2(o), and the average itself must come from a source that can be shown.

Does an improvement claim need a period? The definition covers a product that “has improved its impact over time”. Naming the period, such as “between 2022 and 2025”, and the unit measured lets a reader, an authority or a court check what was compared; under Article 12, courts and authorities may ask for that data.

Sources: Directive 2005/29/EC as consolidated on 27 September 2026, Article 2(o), Articles 6 and 7, including Article 7(7); Directive (EU) 2024/825, recital 6; Directive 2006/114/EC, Articles 2 and 4; French Consumer Code, Article L. 122-1; UWG, section 5b and section 6; National Assembly, bill No 2518, Article 20; COM(2023) 166, Article 4.

General information. Texts cited as they stood on 1 November 2026.

ClaimTrace provides regulatory information: this article cites and dates texts, and draws no conclusion on any company's situation.
Portrait of Jeremy Fain
About the authorJeremy FainFounder of ClaimTrace

Has spent nearly twenty years building software that traces, governs and anticipates. Co-founded Verteego, a publisher of environmental traceability software, in 2007 and chaired it for eleven years.

More about Jeremy Fain
Stay informedOne email at each new stage of the service, never more than one a month.

You will confirm by a link sent by email, and can unsubscribe in one click. The form is loaded from Brevo, our email provider, only when you click.