Shein accepts a record fine
Settlement for misleading commercial practices: fake discounts and the scope of its environmental commitments. A second fine of 1.1 M€ followed for deficient environmental information.
Source: NextGreen claims you can prove.
Doing nothing exposes a company to the legal caps on fines in France and Germany; reviewing claims by hand costs hours for every page. This page sets those caps against the cost of a manual review and of ClaimTrace, with a calculator for your own figures.
An unproven claim is not a copywriting detail: it is a quantified risk, which can be reduced for a fraction of the cost of a manual review.
of its average annual turnover: the cap on the criminal fine a company faces in France (1.5 million euros as a fixed amount), or 80 % of the advertising spend when the practice rests on environmental claims. In Germany, up to 4 % of turnover in the member states concerned, plus injunctions brought by competitors and associations.
Legal caps, not a risk estimate. French Consumer Code, art. L. 132-2; UWG, § 19.a year for 500 product pages, three claims per page, ten minutes per claim and two reviews a year, at 60 € an hour: 500 hours spent finding claims, looking up the rule and recording the review.
An example: replace it with your own figures in the calculator.a year for Core 500 at the launch price, reserved for the first twenty Core customers: 200 € a month and under 5 € per monitored reference, the equivalent of 40 hours of manual review. Finding, rule and record are done; your teams decide.
Excluding VAT. Decisions and evidence remain with your teams.of the environmental claims examined in a European Commission study were vague, misleading or unfounded; 40% had no evidence at all.
Source: European Commission, 2020 study; our analysisof the 1,100 businesses checked by the French consumer authority (DGCCRF) in 2021 and 2022 on their environmental claims were in breach: 141 warnings, 114 injunctions, 18 formal reports.
Source: DGCCRFproceedings brought in Germany by Deutsche Umwelthilfe against “climate neutral” claims, between May 2022 and September 2024.
Source: Deutsche UmwelthilfeSettlement for misleading commercial practices: fake discounts and the scope of its environmental commitments. A second fine of 1.1 M€ followed for deficient environmental information.
Source: NextEnvironmental messages found vague, generic or misleading, including a collection presented as fully recyclable.
Source: Inside RetailH&M and Decathlon commit to correcting their claims and paying 500,000 and 400,000 € to sustainability causes.
Source: ACMClaims of carbon neutrality by 2050 and of being a major player in the energy transition held misleading.
Source: our analysis, in FrenchIncluding offsetting presented as cancelling out the climate impact of flying.
Source: our analysisKatjes: an ambiguous term must be explained in the advertisement itself.
Source: our analysis, in GermanRead on the Blog: Green claims enforcement: the decisions that set the tone; The KLM greenwashing judgment: what it established
And silence costs too: dropping every green argument means giving up sales on products that genuinely made the effort. Read the analysis
Replace the example values with your own. The calculation runs in your browser: nothing is sent.
Hours per year = monitored references × claims × minutes × reviews ÷ 60, where monitored references = products × marketsA market is a country you sell to. A monitored reference is one product page on one market: the same product on two markets counts as two references, so the hours double with each market added.
500 monitored references (products × markets)
This estimates the time spent finding each claim, looking up the applicable rule and recording the review: that is what ClaimTrace does. Decisions and evidence stay with your teams, with or without ClaimTrace. The starting values are examples, not market averages. The saving is the review cost minus the plan price, before any onboarding fee.
The real number of claims on your pages, the free scan measures on five of your addresses.
Two years' imprisonment and a fine of 300,000 euros for an individual, up to 1.5 million euros for a company (Penal Code, Article 131-38); the fine can be raised to 10% of average annual turnover, or to 80% of the advertising expenses when the practice rests on environmental claims; five years and 750,000 euros when the offence is committed through an online public communication service or by means of a digital or electronic medium.
Article L. 132-2 of the Consumer CodeUp to 4% of annual turnover in the Member States concerned, or two million euros where no estimate is possible, when a widespread infringement is pursued in a coordinated action by European authorities; on top of this, competitors and associations can bring injunction claims.
Section 19 of the Act against Unfair Competition (UWG)These are legal maximums, not risk estimates: no probability is calculated here.
You will confirm by a link sent by email, and can unsubscribe in one click. The form is loaded from Brevo, our email provider, only when you click.