Green claims you can prove.
The evidence file for an environmental claim: what each text asks a brand to be able to show, one type of claim at a time
Evidence is not one document. A generic word needs a licence, a label needs a scheme and a certificate, a target needs a plan and an expert’s findings, a pack needs technical documentation. What the texts in force on 1 November 2026 ask for, and how to file it so that it can be produced on the day it is asked for.
Who can ask a brand for the evidence behind an environmental claim?
In 40 words: Courts and authorities. Article 12 of Directive 2005/29/EC lets them require evidence of the accuracy of factual claims and treat a claim as inaccurate when the evidence is missing or insufficient; specific texts add documents of their own, kept ready.
Your own pages: the free scan reads up to five of your addresses and links the claims it finds to the rules that concern them, with their source.
Run a free scanThe general rule: proof on request
Article 12 sets the frame. Courts or administrative authorities may require the trader to furnish evidence as to the accuracy of factual claims where that appears appropriate, and may consider the claims inaccurate if the evidence is not furnished or is deemed insufficient.
The French authority says the same in its own words. In its page of 7 October 2025 on its 2023 investigation, the DGCCRF writes that global claims are presumed misleading when the businesses using them cannot provide the necessary justification.
What the specific rules ask, claim by claim
A generic word needs recognised excellent performance. Point 4a admits it only with performance under the EU Ecolabel, an officially recognised EN ISO 14024 type I label, or top performance under Union law such as energy class A. The file holds the licence, the certificate or the label class, and shows that it covers the whole claim.
A label needs its scheme and its certificate. Recital 7 of Directive (EU) 2024/825 asks the trader, before displaying a label, to check under the scheme’s public terms that it meets minimum conditions of transparency and credibility. The file keeps those terms, the certificate and its scope: product, site, period.
A target needs its plan and the expert’s findings. Article 6(2)(d) requires a detailed and realistic implementation plan, regularly verified by an independent expert whose findings are made available to consumers. The file holds the plan, its resources and milestones, and each report.
A comparison service needs its method. Under Article 7(7), the method, the products compared, their suppliers and the measures to keep the information up to date are material information, so they have to exist in writing before they can be shown.
A durability promise relies on the producer. Recital 20 expects producers to know the durability of their goods, and lets sellers rely on reliable information, such as the producer’s or a competent authority’s.
Packaging, and French rules
Packaging claims rest on technical documentation. Article 14 of Regulation (EU) 2025/40 requires compliance with its conditions to be demonstrated in the technical documentation of Annex VII, which the manufacturer draws up and keeps.
France asks for figures and documents of its own. A recycled claim states the percentage actually incorporated (Article L. 541-9-1 of the Environmental Code); the wordings on recyclability rest on the five criteria of Article R. 541-228; and a carbon neutrality claim in advertising still requires the published greenhouse gas report, reduction trajectory and offsetting terms of Article L. 229-68.
How to file it
One entry per claim, not per product. Each entry holds the exact wording and where it appears, its scope, the document that supports it with its date and version, who checked it, and what would require a new check, such as a new formula or a new supplier.
Keep the version that was true on the day. Article 12 looks at the accuracy of a claim as it was made in a commercial practice; a document dated after the campaign supports a later claim, not the one under review.
Sources: Directive 2005/29/EC as consolidated on 27 September 2026, Articles 2(s), 6(2)(d), 7(7) and 12 and Annex I, points 2a and 4a; Directive (EU) 2024/825, recitals 7, 10 and 20; Regulation (EU) 2025/40, Article 14; DGCCRF, page on its investigation into non-food products and services, 7 October 2025; French Environmental Code, Article L. 541-9-1, Article R. 541-228 and Article L. 229-68.
General information. Texts cited as they stood on 1 November 2026.
You will confirm by a link sent by email, and can unsubscribe in one click. The form is loaded from Brevo, our email provider, only when you click.
