Green claims you can prove.

Analysis

Who is liable when a green claim is wrong: brand, agency, retailer or director

A misleading environmental claim can involve the brand, its agency, the retailer and sometimes the director personally. Who answers for what, and how liability is allocated in practice.

Jeremy Fain · 3 min read

Answer in 40 words: the trader who addresses consumers carries the primary liability, which usually means the brand that puts the product on the market. Agencies, retailers and marketplaces can be involved through their own conduct, and directors are exposed in specific national cases.

Your own pages: the free scan reads up to five of your addresses and links the claims it finds to the rules that concern them, with their source.

Run a free scan

The default rule

Unfair commercial practices law targets the trader whose commercial communication reaches the consumer. For a branded product, that is the brand owner, even when the wording was drafted by an agency and the listing was published by a marketplace. Delegation moves the work, not the responsibility. This is why internal sign-off matters more than the quality of the agency brief.

Where the others enter the picture

The agency, through its contract with the brand rather than through consumer law: indemnity clauses decide who bears the cost, and they are negotiated before the campaign, not after the complaint.

The retailer or distributor, when it writes its own product descriptions or amplifies a claim in its own promotions.

The marketplace, for its own communications and, increasingly, through platform obligations to act on notices of prohibited content (Article 16 of the Digital Services Act).

The director, in national regimes where personal liability attaches to specific offences, which is a reason boards ask for evidence of a documented process rather than assurances.

What allocation looks like in practice

Three documents decide the outcome long before a dispute: the contract with the agency, the sign-off record showing who approved a claim and on what basis, and the evidence file supporting the claim at the date of publication. Companies that hold the three settle quickly. Companies that hold none negotiate blind, whatever their contracts say.

Frequently asked questions

Does an agency disclaimer transfer liability? Not towards consumers or authorities. It allocates cost between the parties.

What single artefact reduces exposure most? A dated record linking each claim to the rule applied, its version, the evidence and the person who approved it.

Does approval by the client's legal team protect the agency? It documents the process on both sides, which usually shortens the argument about who decided what.

ClaimTrace provides regulatory information: this article cites and dates texts, and draws no conclusion on any company's situation.
Portrait of Jeremy Fain
About the authorJeremy FainFounder of ClaimTrace

Has spent nearly twenty years building software that traces, governs and anticipates. Co-founded Verteego, a publisher of environmental traceability software, in 2007 and chaired it for eleven years.

More about Jeremy Fain
Stay informedOne email at each new stage of the service, never more than one a month.

You will confirm by a link sent by email, and can unsubscribe in one click. The form is loaded from Brevo, our email provider, only when you click.