Green claims you can prove.
Private label green claims: when the retailer is also the brand
On own-brand products the distributor carries the claim, the supplier holds the evidence and the buying team sets the specification. How responsibility and proof are organised in practice.
Answer in 40 words: the retailer is the trader placing the product on the market under its own name, so it carries the claim towards consumers. The manufacturing supplier holds most of the evidence, which makes the buying specification the place where substantiation is either secured or lost.
Your own pages: the free scan reads up to five of your addresses and links the claims it finds to the rules that concern them, with their source.
Run a free scanThe structural asymmetry
On a national brand, the party making the claim usually holds the evidence. On an own-brand product, the two are separated: the retailer writes the pack, the supplier knows the formula, the material and the process. Every substantiation therefore travels through a commercial relationship, at the speed of that relationship, and it is renegotiated at every tender.
Where own-brand claims typically fail
The specification asks for a claim rather than an attribute: requiring a recycled content mention rather than a stated percentage with a test method invites the supplier to supply words instead of evidence.
Supplier change without claim review: a new source at the same price wins the tender, the artwork stays, the evidence no longer matches.
Range-wide wording: one sentence applied across a range whose references have different specifications.
Evidence that never left the supplier: an attestation shown during the tender and never filed by the retailer.
What a buying specification should contain
Four lines are enough to change the outcome: the exact attribute and its unit, the test or attestation required, the obligation to notify any change affecting it, and the right to receive the underlying document rather than a summary. These lines cost nothing at tender stage and are almost impossible to obtain afterwards, when the product is already on shelf and the claim is already printed.
Frequently asked questions
Can the supplier be pursued instead? The retailer carries the consumer-facing claim. Recourse against the supplier is a contractual matter, decided by the contract signed before the problem.
Does an audit of the supplier replace the evidence file? An audit covers a site or a process at a date. A claim about a product still needs the product level document.
What is the fastest improvement? Adding the four lines above to the standard buying template, applied to new tenders from today.
Who keeps the file when the supplier changes? The retailer, if it required the document at tender stage rather than a summary.
You will confirm by a link sent by email, and can unsubscribe in one click. The form is loaded from Brevo, our email provider, only when you click.
