Green claims you can prove.
Beyond carbon: water, biodiversity and soil claims
Most attention goes to carbon, yet water saving, biodiversity friendly and regenerative claims are harder to substantiate. What each family demands, and where they fail.
Short version: these families need a place and a period, which carbon claims can sometimes avoid. Water abstracted in a stressed basin is not comparable with water used elsewhere, biodiversity effects are local by nature, and soil claims describe practices whose results appear over years.
Your own pages: the free scan reads up to five of your addresses and links the claims it finds to the rules that concern them, with their source.
Run a free scanWhy they are harder than carbon
A tonne of carbon dioxide has the same effect wherever it is emitted, which is why a single global figure can carry meaning. Water does not work that way. Neither does biodiversity. Saving a cubic metre in a water-abundant region and in a stressed basin are different acts, and averaging them produces a number that describes nothing. This is not a technicality: it is the reason a water claim without a location is close to empty.
What each family requires
Water: the stage measured, the location, and whether the figure is abstraction, consumption or a scarcity weighted indicator. Three different numbers hide behind the phrase water use.
Biodiversity: a described practice on a described area, with a baseline. Friendly to biodiversity as a product attribute rarely survives a question about which species and which habitat.
Soil and regenerative practices: the practices themselves, the hectares covered and the duration, rather than an outcome that takes years to appear and is measured on the plot, not on the pack.
Marine claims: the fishery or the farm and its certification scope, which travels badly to a whole range.
The claim that quietly generalises
A brand sources one ingredient from a project it funds, and the pack says the product supports biodiversity. The project may be real and well run. The claim still generalises from one ingredient to the whole product, which is the pattern behind most challenged environmental messages. Naming the ingredient and the project fixes it, and makes the story better.
Common questions
Can a certification carry a biodiversity claim? Within its scope and criteria, which are usually narrower than the marketing sentence built on them.
Are water figures comparable between brands? Rarely, because the boundaries differ. Stating your boundary is what makes your figure usable.
Is regenerative a protected term? Definitions vary between schemes, so the safe route is to describe practices rather than to rely on the word.
You will confirm by a link sent by email, and can unsubscribe in one click. The form is loaded from Brevo, our email provider, only when you click.
