Green claims you can prove.

Analysis

One part, the whole product: what point 4b bans, and how an environmental claim keeps to its scope

A claim made about a whole product, range or company when only its packaging, one material or one site supports it is banned outright since 27 September 2026. The text, the two cases its recital gives, the packaging rule that runs alongside, and where France and Germany stand.

Jeremy Fain · Published on 2 November 2026 · 5 min read

The question this article answers
Can a product be called “made with recycled material” when only its packaging is?

In 40 words: No. Since 27 September 2026, point 4b of Annex I to Directive 2005/29/EC bans presenting a claim about one aspect as a claim about the whole product or business. A claim about packaging must say it concerns only the packaging.

Your own pages: the free scan reads up to five of your addresses and links the claims it finds to the rules that concern them, with their source.

Run a free scan

What point 4b bans

The point is short and admits no exception. It bans “making an environmental claim about the entire product or the trader’s entire business when it concerns only a certain aspect of the product or a specific activity of the trader’s business”. Annex I lists practices regarded as unfair in all circumstances, so no case-by-case test of the consumer’s decision applies; Member States apply the point from 27 September 2026.

Recital 11 of Directive (EU) 2024/825 gives two cases. A product marketed as “made with recycled material”, giving the impression that all of it is recycled, when only the packaging is; and a trader giving the impression that it uses only renewable energy when several of its facilities still use fossil fuels.

The same recital says what stays open. A trader may still make claims about its entire business, provided they are accurate and verifiable and do not overstate the benefit: the second trader could report a decrease in the use of fossil fuels for the business as a whole. The recital speaks of an activity that is “specific, unrepresentative”, and that word marks the target.

Where the leap from part to whole happens

Packaging is the first place to look. A carton of recycled fibre, a refill pouch or a bottle with recycled plastic is part of the sales unit, and a claim printed next to the product name reads as a statement about what the consumer buys.

One material, one ingredient or one stage is an aspect. An organic share in a blend, a renewable ingredient in a formula or a low-carbon transport leg can be claimed as such; the wording and the layout decide whether the claim stays there or spreads to the product.

One site or one reference is not the whole business. A plant running on renewable electricity supports a claim about that plant. Written as “our production runs on renewable energy”, the same fact covers sites the evidence never measured, and a figure measured on one reference does not travel to the range page.

The overall presentation counts. Article 6(1) of Directive 2005/29/EC judges whether a practice deceives “in any way, including overall presentation”: a leaf beside the brand name rather than beside the packaging line can widen the scope of an accurate sentence.

How a claim keeps to its scope

Name the part in the claim itself. “Carton: 80% recycled fibre” or “bottle made from 50% recycled plastic, cap excluded” states its object. The same fact turned into a badge next to the product name no longer does.

Packaging claims carry their own scope rule. Article 14 of Regulation (EU) 2025/40, applicable since 12 August 2026, requires an environmental claim on a packaging property that the regulation governs to specify whether it relates to the packaging unit, to part of it, or to all packaging the economic operator places on the market.

Check the scope again when a sentence travels. A product-page line reused in a campaign or on a marketplace listing describes something larger there.

Where France and Germany stand

Germany took the point over word for word. Annex No 4b of the Act against Unfair Competition (UWG), headed “unwahre Angabe zur Reichweite einer Umweltaussage”, an untrue statement on the reach of an environmental claim, applies towards consumers; between businesses, the general ban on misleading practices in section 5 remains.

France had not transposed the point on 1 November 2026. Article L. 121-4 of the Consumer Code does not list it, and the bill adopted by the Senate on 18 February 2026 would add it. Until then, the general rule on misleading practices in Article L. 121-2 remains the route against a claim that overstates its scope.

Questions we hear

Can a claim still be made about a component? Yes, as a specific claim: the ban targets the leap from the part to the whole. The component claim must then be accurate and substantiated like any other.

Does point 4b reach services? The point names the trader’s entire business as well as the product, and Article 2(c) of Directive 2005/29/EC defines a product as any good or service.

Sources: Directive 2005/29/EC as consolidated on 27 September 2026, Article 2(c), Article 6(1) and Annex I, point 4b; Directive (EU) 2024/825, recital 11; Regulation (EU) 2025/40, Article 14; UWG, section 5 and annex, No 4b; French Consumer Code, Articles L. 121-2 and L. 121-4; text adopted by the French Senate on 18 February 2026, Article 20.

General information. Texts cited as they stood on 1 November 2026.

ClaimTrace provides regulatory information: this article cites and dates texts, and draws no conclusion on any company's situation.
Portrait of Jeremy Fain
About the authorJeremy FainFounder of ClaimTrace

Has spent nearly twenty years building software that traces, governs and anticipates. Co-founded Verteego, a publisher of environmental traceability software, in 2007 and chaired it for eleven years.

More about Jeremy Fain
Stay informedOne email at each new stage of the service, never more than one a month.

You will confirm by a link sent by email, and can unsubscribe in one click. The form is loaded from Brevo, our email provider, only when you click.