Green claims you can prove.

Analysis

Third-party labels: the four criteria a certification scheme must meet since 27 September 2026

A label run by a third party is not, by that fact alone, based on a certification scheme. Article 2(r) of Directive 2005/29/EC sets four criteria, and the scheme’s public terms have to show them.

Jeremy Fain · Published on 1 November 2026 · 4 min read

The question this article answers
What does Article 2(r) require of a certification scheme?

In 40 words: four criteria, readable in its public terms: openness to every trader able to meet the requirements, requirements developed with experts and stakeholders, withdrawal or suspension after a breach, and monitoring by a third party independent of both owner and trader.

Your own pages: the free scan reads up to five of your addresses and links the claims it finds to the rules that concern them, with their source.

Run a free scan

What point 2a bans, and the two ways out

Point 2a of Annex I bans displaying a sustainability label that is neither based on a certification scheme nor established by public authorities. A sustainability label is any voluntary trust mark, quality mark or equivalent, public or private, that sets a product, process or business apart for its environmental or social characteristics (Article 2(q)); mandatory labels are excluded.

A label established by public authorities is the first way out. Recital 7 of Directive (EU) 2024/825 gives as examples the logos awarded under the EMAS Regulation (EC) No 1221/2009 and the EU Ecolabel Regulation (EC) No 66/2010.

A certification scheme is the second, and its definition is demanding. Article 2(r) means a third-party verification scheme whose terms, requirements included, are publicly available and meet four criteria. A label managed by a body outside the brand does not meet them for that reason alone.

The criteria, one at a time

The scheme is open to all traders willing and able to meet its requirements. The terms must be transparent, fair and non-discriminatory. A label that only a federation’s members or one retailer’s suppliers can obtain raises this question first.

The requirements are developed by the scheme owner in consultation with relevant experts and stakeholders. Ask for the record of that consultation: who was consulted, when, on which version of the standard.

The scheme sets procedures for breaches, with withdrawal or suspension of the label. The terms say what happens to a holder who fails an audit. A standard that is silent on the point misses the third criterion.

Monitoring follows an objective procedure and is done by a third party independent of both the scheme owner and the trader. Competence and independence rest on international, Union or national standards and procedures; recital 7 cites ISO 17065 and the accreditation mechanisms of Regulation (EC) No 765/2008. The accreditation of the auditing body, with its scope, can usually be checked in the public directory of the national accreditation body.

Before keeping a label on a pack

The check is documentary. Article 2(r) requires the scheme’s terms to be publicly available, so a scheme that will not show its standard fails before any discussion.

Scope matters as much as the scheme. The certificate must cover the product shown, the production site and the period; keep its number or link at hand, and name the scheme next to the claim.

A climate label based on offsetting stays caught, whatever the scheme. A logo presenting the product as climate neutral or compensated falls under point 4c of the same annex.

National rules, today

Germany wrote the definitions into its Act against Unfair Competition. Section 2(2) UWG defines the sustainability label, with the words “gegenüber Verbrauchern”, and the certification scheme with the same four criteria; items 2 and 2a of its annex cover a quality mark used without authorisation and a sustainability label without a scheme.

France keeps its older rule until the transposition passes. On 1 November 2026, Article L. 121-4 of the French Consumer Code still deems misleading the display of a certificate, quality label or equivalent without the necessary authorisation (2°). The bill adopted by the Senate would add the label without a certification scheme (2° bis) and define the scheme in a new Article L. 434-1; the final wording is still to be voted.

Questions we are asked

Is a brand’s own label with an outside auditor enough? The text requires a monitor independent of both the scheme owner and the trader. Whether a brand can own a scheme that is open to all and monitored independently is not settled by the text, and remains to be clarified.

And a label shown only to business customers? Annex I covers practices towards consumers; between businesses, the general rules on misleading advertising apply.

Sources: Directive 2005/29/EC as consolidated on 27 September 2026, Article 2, points (q) and (r), and Annex I, points 2 and 2a; Directive (EU) 2024/825, recital 7; UWG, section 2 and annex; French Consumer Code, Article L. 121-4; text adopted by the French Senate on 18 February 2026, Article 20.

General information. Texts cited as they stood on 1 November 2026.

ClaimTrace provides regulatory information: this article cites and dates texts, and draws no conclusion on any company's situation.
Portrait of Jeremy Fain
About the authorJeremy FainFounder of ClaimTrace

Has spent nearly twenty years building software that traces, governs and anticipates. Co-founded Verteego, a publisher of environmental traceability software, in 2007 and chaired it for eleven years.

More about Jeremy Fain
Stay informedOne email at each new stage of the service, never more than one a month.

You will confirm by a link sent by email, and can unsubscribe in one click. The form is loaded from Brevo, our email provider, only when you click.