Green claims you can prove.
Generic or specific: where the line falls for environmental claims since 27 September 2026
“Eco-friendly” is now banned without recognised performance; “87% recycled PET” is not. Between the two runs a line that many tools cross wrongly, in both directions.
How do you tell a generic claim, which is banned, from a specific claim, which must be substantiated?
In 40 words: a generic claim stays vague about the environmental aspect it claims, and is banned unless recognised excellent performance is shown. A specific claim names that aspect, a material, a substance, a figure: it is not banned, but must be substantiated.
Your own pages: the free scan reads up to five of your addresses and links the claims it finds to the rules that concern them, with their source.
Run a free scanWhat the directive calls generic
Directive (EU) 2024/825 targets claims such as “environmentally friendly”, “eco-friendly”, “green”, “nature's friend” or “climate friendly” when their specification is not given clearly and prominently on the same medium. The word is not banned in itself: the lack of specification is.
What makes it specific
Naming a material, “organic cotton”, an absent substance, “microplastic-free”, a proportion, “87% recycled PET”, or a measurement, “20% less wear”. Each becomes a verifiable statement: it must be substantiated, with the method, scope and date of the measurement. It is not banned for all that.
Two frequent confusions
The badge taken for a label. A sustainability label sets a product apart by its environmental or social characteristics; it is banned if it rests neither on a certification scheme nor on a public authority. A “Made in France” badge is not one: it says where, not how.
The figure taken for a durability promise. The directive bans falsely claiming that a product lasts a certain time or withstands a certain intensity of use. A measured figure such as “20% less wear” is not that promise: it is a comparison, which must be substantiated.
What ClaimTrace does with it
The engine cites the generic-claim rule only on a vague claim; a specific claim falls under the rule that targets it, usually “to be evidenced”. Every rule carries its counter-examples, and the engine never declares a claim free of risk: a person decides that nothing needs doing.
Frequently asked questions
Is “biodegradable” generic? It can be: without specifying the environment and the time frame, the mention stays vague. Specified, it becomes a claim to be evidenced.
Can a specific claim be banned? Yes, if it is false or misleading, or if it falls under another prohibition, such as carbon neutrality based on offsetting.
Can a generic claim be kept? Only if the trader demonstrates recognised excellent environmental performance, for instance through an official ecolabel relevant to the claim.
You will confirm by a link sent by email, and can unsubscribe in one click. The form is loaded from Brevo, our email provider, only when you click.
