Green claims you can prove.
“Made in France”, “vegan”, “100% cotton”: what is not an environmental claim
The 2024 directive targets environmental claims. Origin, diet and composition follow other rules. Knowing where the line runs avoids two mistakes: correcting everything, or seeing nothing.
Do an origin statement, a “vegan” mention or a composition fall under the new rules on environmental claims?
In 40 words: no, as long as they promise no benefit for the environment. An environmental claim states or implies a positive, or lesser, impact on the environment. Saying where a product is made, which diet it suits or what it contains informs; it does not promise.
Your own pages: the free scan reads up to five of your addresses and links the claims it finds to the rules that concern them, with their source.
Run a free scanThree families of mentions outside the scope
Origin. “Made in France”, “made in Germany”: origin falls under the rules on the origin of goods and the ban on misleading consumers about geographical origin. On its own, it says nothing about environmental impact.
Diet. “Vegan”, “no animal-derived ingredients”: the mention describes composition with regard to a dietary or ethical choice. It falls under consumer information law and, for cosmetics, under the common criteria for cosmetic claims.
Composition. “50% cotton, 50% linen”: stating the fibre composition of textiles is in fact mandatory under the EU regulation on textile fibre names. It is information, not a promise.
Where the line gives way
Everything changes once an environmental benefit is added, stated or suggested: “vegan, so better for the planet”, “made in France to cut our footprint”, “organic cotton”. The mention then becomes an environmental claim, and it must be specific and substantiated like any other.
Context counts as much as words. A green leaf next to an origin badge can be enough to suggest what the text does not say, and consumers remember the whole.
Why not flag everything
A tool that flags everything drowns the real risks. Flagging “Made in Germany” as an environmental claim forces a team to justify what needs no justification, and makes it doubt the rest of the report.
ClaimTrace therefore leaves these mentions out of its analysis, unless they carry an environmental benefit. It is a method decision, written into its rulebook and dated.
Frequently asked questions
Is a mention outside the scope unregulated? No: it remains subject to the general ban on misleading commercial practices and to its own rules. It simply does not fall under the new rules on environmental claims.
Is “microplastic-free” outside the scope? No: the absence of a substance is presented as a benefit for the environment. It is a specific claim, which must be substantiated.
Does ClaimTrace still flag these mentions? No, it does not count them as claims; it flags them only when an environmental benefit comes with them.
You will confirm by a link sent by email, and can unsubscribe in one click. The form is loaded from Brevo, our email provider, only when you click.
